Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Lindsey B.'s avatar

This one hits close to home for me. Raised (steeped) in fundamentalist religion from the moment I was born up until I was brave enough to set it all down (after becoming a mother). I couldn’t raise my little one in the painful traditions that I was raised in; I was taught very young to hate myself in the name of Jesus and I still work everyday to cope with the effects of that and other insidious aspects of religion. So, in my experience, that is “what’s wrong” with people believing it. Not so much that they think that there’s life after - to each their own - but that they make life so painful for so many people (children) in the meantime, under the guise of doing something of utmost importance. Something that cannot be questioned, or else.

Somewhere along my deconstruction journey, I landed on the belief that the concept of sin is a trauma response- there’s a lot of complex trauma in this life and instead of having a multilayered view on the causes of the pain/harm, it was painted over with the concept of inherent sin. “People aren’t struggling to cope due to fractured systems that exploit and harm families and incidentally hurt people along the way, they’re just born sinful.” It still makes my skin crawl. It’s been my focus over the past several years to understand life as best I can through a completely different lens; one where I believe that behavior is simply a result of needs that have or haven’t been met. A world full of grey rather than black and white. One where myself and others are deserving of true compassion, because we’re just here to experience, not to judge each other. Even despite the harm I experienced, there are beautiful aspects of the religious experience - I just don’t think the doctrine is responsible for that. I think the beauty comes from humans in community, and that can occur outside of the realm of religiosity.

Thanks for sharing this, Serge.

Expand full comment
W. D. Ehrhart's avatar

It is my belief that the origin of all religions and all philosophies is rooted in the attempt to answer one question: "What does it all Mean?" And the terrible fear that the answer is: "Nothing at all."

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts